The Talenti Gelato Flavor Number List

Ok, I have done my best to compile a list of all known Talenti flavors and their corresponding numbers. Please keep in mind that the numbers didn't kick in until 2013, so the order may seem a little off. Also, not every store has every flavor, so it took a bit of investigating to nail this list down. Thanks to everyone that helped finish off the list!

2013 -  1  Argentine Caramel (retired)
20__ -  2  Madagascar Vanilla Bean
20__ -  3  Double Dark Chocolate
20__ -  4. Roman Raspberry sorbetto
20__ -  5  Belgian (Milk) Chocolate
20__ -  6  Toasted Almond (Limited in 2018, then retired)
2012 -  7  Coffee Chocolate Chip
20__ -  8  Black Cherry (amarena) (retired)
20__ -  9  Caribbean Coconut
2012 - 10  Chocolate Chip (Stracciatella) (retired for 2019)
20__ - 11  Lisbon Lemon sorbetto (retired)
20__ - 12  Caramel Cookie Crunch
20__ - 13  Mediterranean Mint
2012 - 14  Simply Strawberry (retired for 2019)
20__ - 15  Sicilian Pistachio
2012 - 16  Banana Chocolate Swirl (retired)
20__ - 17  Old World Eggnog (seasonal - retired)
20__ - 18  Blood Orange sorbetto (retired)
2011 - 19  Sea Salt Caramel
2012 - 20  Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
2012 - 21  Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip

2013 - 22. Alphonso Mango sorbetto
2013 - 23  Peppermint Bark (seasonal)
2013 - 24  German Chocolate Cake (retired)
2013 - 25  Southern Butter Pecan
2013 - 26  Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel (Publix Exclusive)

2014 - 27  Raspberries & Cream (retired)
2014 - 28  Fudge Brownie (retired)
2014 - 29  Caramel Apple Pie (seasonal starting 2018)
2014 - 30  Pumpkin Pie (seasonal)

2015 - 31  Raspberry Cheesecake
2015 - 32  Hazelnut Chocolate Chip (retired)
2015 - 33  Salted Peanut Caramel (retired)
2015 - 34  Coffee Toffee (retired)
2015 - 35  Oatmeal Raisin Cookie (retired)
2015 - 36  Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
2015 - 37  Tiramisu (retired)

2016 - 38  Chocolate Sorbetto (retired for 2019)
2016 - 39  Vanilla Caramel Swirl
2016 - 40  Coconut Almond Chocolate (Retired)
2016 - 41  Key Lime Pie (seasonal starting 2018)
2016 - 42  Peanut Butter Pretzel (retired)
2016 - 43  Wild Blackberry (retired)

2017 - 44  Cinnamon Peach Biscuit (retired for 2019)
2017 - 45  Peanut Butter Fudge Sorbetto (retired)
2017 - 46  Vanilla Blueberry Crumble (retired)
2017 - 47  Vanilla Chai (seasonal for last run in 2019)

2018 - 48  Chocolate Caramel Blondie (one year only!)
2018 - 49  Almond Butter & Honey (special batch, retired)
2018 - 50  Vanilla Cinnamon (120 cal) (retired)
2018 - 51  Cold Brew Coffee Sorbetto
2018 - 52  Mint Cookie Crunch (120 cal) (retired)
2018 - 53  Chocolate Fudge Swirl (120 cal) (retired)

2019 - 54 Organic Ginger Matcha Gelato (retired)
2019 - 55 Organic Oak-Aged Vanilla Gelato
2019 - 56 Organic Chocolate Mousse Gelato
2019 - 57 Organic Brown Butter Caramel Gelato (Retired)
2019 - 58 Less Sugar Lemon Bar Gelato (one year only!)
2019 - 66? Peanut Butter Vanilla Fudge Layers?
2019 - 67 Dark Chocolate Cherry Layers

2020 - 59 Dark Chocolate Dairy-Free Sorbetto
2020 - 60 Strawberry Hibiscus Dairy-Free Sorbetto (Retired)
2020 - 69` Lemon Berry Pie Layers (Retired)
2020 - 71` Banana Caramel Crunch Layers (Retired 2021)
2020 - 72 Pumpkin Pie Layers (late Fall debut)

2021 - 61~ Honey Graham
2021 - 75 Cookies & Cream Layers
2021 - 77?  (new honey graham number?)
2021 - 78?  (new vanilla pb swirl number?)
2021 - 79 Peanut Butter Crunch Layers

2022 - 81 Bourbon Fudge Brownie Pairings
2022 - 82 Salted Chocolate Churro Pairings
2022 - 83 Caramel Pretzel Blondie Gelato Pairings

(Target 2014)  Hazelnut
(Target 2015)  Coconut Chocolate Chip
(Publix 2016)  Peach Butter Biscuit - no longer exclusive in 2017

Retired (all before 2012 I believe)
-chocolate hazelnut gelato
-dulce de leche caramel gelato
-white chocolate raspberry gelato
-malaysian mango sorbetto
-sonoma strawberry sorbetto
-hill country peach champagne sorbetto

In 2012 Cappuccino became Coffee Chocolate Chip

61* and 62* are the new numbering scheme, 61~ and 62~ are the old numbering scheme. 
69` and 71`  are both listed as 71 on the website, so I guessed

Disclaimer: I do not claim this list is perfect, it's just done to the best of my knowledge.

21 comments:

Anonymous said...

Chocolate Hazelnut was recently spotted at Target.

Dubba Scoops said...

are you talking "hazelnut chocolate chip" or do you mean literal "chocolate hazelnut"?

Staci said...

I am so excited I found this list. I recently discovered these gelatos and have created a list on my phone to fill out as I buy and try all the flavors. Nom nom nom.

Dubba Scoops said...

Glad to help!

Adam said...

Sicilian Pistacchiooooosodelicious!

Steven John Rodriguez said...

My favorite is Caramel Cookie Crunch! And I love Peppermint Bark when it's available.

J B said...

Recently tried Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip. Seriously yummy! Peach Butter Biscuit was ok but nothing special. Mediterranean Mint, Sicilian Pistachio and Caramel Apple Pie were disappointing. Sea Salt Caramel remains the all-time favorite.

Joili said...

I've been trying to find number 1 for the longest time now and I was confused since Vanilla wasn't the first one. I'm really surprised at this new information.

Dubba Scoops said...

That's why I built the list, to make sense of it all :)

Anonymous said...

I tried the vanilla blueberry crumble. not worth it! All it is is a lesser blueberry version of Gelato Fiasco flavor and that's not saying allot since that flavor of there's went downhill since the last time i had it.

Everett Howe said...

Perhaps the people who find this list will appreciate this video...
http://alumnus.caltech.edu/~however/video/Talenti.mov

The empty spot where #26 should be is there because I have not managed to visit an area where there are Publix supermarkets...

Dubba Scoops said...

@Everett: that's pretty funny! I may have made this list but even my collection is missing a few containers :)

Anonymous said...

No. 44 Is Cinnamon Peach Biscuit

Dubba Scoops said...

Correct! I got the tip several weeks ago but forgot to update, plus I still havent found it myself.

Unknown said...

Thank you SO MUCH for putting us out of our misery. This is the only list of it's kind and is magnificent!!

Unknown said...

# 2 Madagascar vanilla in Florida Publix supermarkets
I really want the chocolate sorbetto
Can’t locate att all. Walgreens Publix
Maybe wal mart has some

Dubba Scoops said...

@Larry: yes, the name has changed every few years, I will update it on this list. Just keep searching different stores, hopefully you will find the chocolate.

Renato R S said...

You've labored so hard on this! I think this list should be added to the "Talenti" article in Wikipedia.

Dubba Scoops said...

HA! I hadn't thought of that!

I scream said...

I have a older #2 jar that is called "Tahitian Vanilla Bean".

Dubba Scoops said...

Should have clicked on the #2 link before posting, you will see all -THREE- iterations of the container. Tahitian to plain to Madagascar.