Talenti Chocolate Chip Cookie Batter

[New for Early 2025] Yes, I gave in and tried Snickerdoodle first, and it's a solid flavor, but let's see if this one cant bring the thunder.

Talenti Chocolate Chip Cookie Batter Bakery Collection Gelato Layers

chocolate chip cookie gelato - shortbread cookies - cookie batter - vanilla gelato - chocolate cookies

Talenti Snickerdoodle Cookie

[New for Early 2025] I was running through Stop & Shop when I found two of the new bakery collection lineup. They didn't have Tiramisu, but they did have chocolate chip cookie batter and....

Talenti Snickerdoodle Cookie Bakery Collection Gelato Layers

snickerdoodle cookie gelato - cinnamon cookies - snickerdoodle cookie batter - vanilla gelato - cinnamon cookie pieces

Haagen-Dazs Salted Brown Butter Cookie

[New for 2025] I went to Hannaford with the mild hope of finding something new. Well, I came home with one of the new Ben & Jerry's Sundae flavors and also....

Haagen-Dazs Salted Brown Butter Cookie Ice Cream

brown butter ice cream with milk chocolaty chips and cookie pieces with a touch of salt

Pumpkin Pie Crumbl Cookie

I hope everyone had a nice Thanksgiving weekend. Mine started with this delicious Pumpkin Pie Crumbl Cookie. This was my first true test of their offerings and it did not disappoint. Who knew you could turn a cookie in to a pie like this?

The soft crumbly sugar cookie mixed with the pumpkin pie filling worked really well, and the whipped cream sealed the deal. In fact, I wouldn't have minded a little more of it as a bite with all three components was delicious.

Have a good week everyone!

Haagan-Dazs Black & White Cookie Ice Cream

[New for 2022] Let's check out the last non-nutty pint in the new city sweets lineup. So far it's been a bit of hit and miss so let's see what's inside...

Haagan-Dazs Black & White Cookie Ice Cream

vanilla bean ice cream with soft cookie pieces and ripples of chocolate frosting

Wegman's Shortbread Cookie Ice Cream

It's now December and I'm still doling out what I bought from Wegman's in October. Come on 2021, get here soon! We need you! (for many reasons). Let's dive in to....

Wegman's Shortbread Cookie Ice Cream

sugar cookie flavored ice cream with cookie pieces & festive sprinkles

Whole Foods Butter Cookies & Sweet Cream Gelato

[New for 2019] Hey, for the record, I am not ice cream hunting right now, it's just not worth the risk of bringing germs home. That said, we can still try to have fun, like this catchy looking pint of Whole Foods gelato. Yes, I still hate Whole Foods in general, but this was too tempting.

Whole Foods Butter Cookies & Sweet Cream Gelato

(sweet cream gelato, salted caramel butter sauce, butter cookies)

Chipwich Birthday Cake Ice Cream Sandwich

[New for 2020] After a failed run to Roche Bros in the morning (aka no new products), I ran out to Stop & Shop and lunch to grab something new for my belly. I only saw my first picture of this product yesterday, so I was stoked to find...

Chipwich Birthday Cake Ice Cream Sandwich

sugar cookies, rainbow sprinkles, birthday cake ice cream

Oatmeal Cookie Chunk from Outside the Cone

On September 9th, 2019, Outside the Cone opened it's doors in Wyndhurst, Virginia. On January 19th, 2020, they sent me a direct message on instagram. Kyle asked me if I would be willing to try their version of Oatmeal Cookie Chunk. That's right, it's meant to replicate that badly missed Ben & Jerry's (archived here). Did I say yes? Ofcourse!

Outside the Cone Oatmeal Cookie Chunk Ice Cream

(cinnamon ice cream with oatmeal cookie chunks and chocolate chunks)

Big Gay Ice Cream - Dorothy

[New for 2017]  You may find this shocking, but I've actually be trying to avoid chocolate lately. The problem is, what do I buy then? Oh, this will work..

Big Gay Ice Cream - Dorothy

vanilla ice cream with vanilla wafer cookies
& thick swirls of dulce de leche

Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Chipwich

[New for 2019, discontinued] So what do you do when an ice cream company wants to send you samples of their latest product? You accept ofcourse! I enjoyed the return of Chipwich last year so it's cool to see them already spicing things up.

Chipwich Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

Oreo Vanilla Crunch State Fair Cookie

[New for 2018] Hey everyone, I know things are really really slow right now, but just so you know I'm still alive, here is a review of those new frozen Oreo treats that popped up this year. (You may remember that I thought Oreo Churros were kind of horrible).

Oreo Vanilla Crunch State Fair Cookie

crunchy vanilla coating on chocolate flavored sandwich cookies

Homemade Brand Santa's Cookies Ice Cream

Ok, technically Nick has already reviewed this one, but it was five years ago. In fact, he did all of our Homemade Brand (and UDF) reviews back then. Well, Homemade Brand's PR company contacted me and offered to send over some free holiday samples, so now it's finally my turn to say "wow this stuff makes a great first impression".

Homemade Brand Santa's Cookies Ice Cream

Sugar cookie ice cream with cookie pieces and icing swirls

Museum Of Ice Cream Vanillionaire Ice Cream

[New for Summer 2018] Have you ever heard of the Museum of Ice Cream? Maybe not, but you have probably seen a picture on social media of someone "swimming" around their giant pool of ice cream sprinkles. Well, for some reason they have gotten in to the ice cream game.... I should probably look for a press release. found it. Apparently the seven pint flavors will be exclusive to Target (and any Museum of Ice Cream location).

Museum Of Ice Cream Vanillionaire Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with wafer cookies

The Original Chipwich Returns

[Returning for 2018] So the Chipwich has returned. I feel like we all know chipwich (or a clone of it). Vanilla ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies that's been rolled in chocolate chips. Maybe you used to get them during school lunch? I think I did, unless it was the tollhouse version, it was kind of a long time ago. The good news is that they are back after an 8+ year hiatus (you can read more over on wikipedia). Are you ready to see if they look as good as you remember?

The Original Chipwich

chocolate chip cookie sandwich with premium vanilla ice cream

Big Friendly Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

[New for 2018] Do you ever buy something and then think about it constantly until you can finally take the time to try it out properly? That's how I felt about this next treat.

Big Friendly Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich

vanilla ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies and rolled in chocolate chips

Haagen-Dazs Vanilla Ice Cream Cookie Squares

[2018-2021] Time to dig in to some more free Haagen-Dazs samples! They've got two new cookie squares this year (think super premium bunny snacks) and I'm about to try the non dulce de leche version. Fingers crossed that the cookie layer is awesome!

Haagen-Dazs Vanilla Ice Cream Cookie Squares

chocolate cookie topped with vanilla ice cream, dipped in dark chocolate

Breyers Oreo & Chips Ahoy! 2in1

[New for early 2018] You remember my post about how Breyers Blasts are dead and we are getting four new 2 in 1 flavors in their place right? Well most stores are still pushing out the remaining Blasts stock but Price Chopper finally started putting out the new stuff in my area. Since the other three all have nut components, looks like the only one that is safe to bring home is...

Breyers Oreo & Chips Ahoy! 2in1

vanilla frozen dairy dessert with Oreo chunks swirled with
caramel frozen dairy dessert with Chips Ahoy chunks

Apple Pie Oreos & The Nosh Show Ep. 111

Hey Nosh Show Listeners! Episode 111 is live and ready to brighten up your long Labor Day weekend. One of the things we talk about is techniques for tracking down new products like the new Apple Pie Oreos. As you can see below, the discussion paid off.

Apple Pie Oreos

Ben & Jerry's Keep Caramel and Cookie On Ice Cream

[New for 2017] Four months. FOUR MONTHS. I have patiently waited four months to try this Target exclusive. I am four hours away from Ben & Jerry's HQ yet I had to wait four months to try this excellent flavor. Wait, should I have said spoiler alert first?

Ben & Jerry's Keep Caramel and Cookie On Ice Cream

caramel malt ice cream with shortbread cookies, fudge flakes & caramel swirl