Bettergoods Spiced Apple Pie Ice Cream

[New for Fall 2026] I usually avoid Walmart ice cream because of the cross contamination warning (and general low expectations), but when a commenter mentioned that this one reminded them of the old Edy's apple pie flavor, I couldn't help but pick up a container of....

Bettergoods Spiced Apple Pie Ice Cream

sea salt caramel ice cream with cinnamon spiced apples and pie crust pieces

DQ Caramel Apple Cheesecake Blizzard

[New for August 2026] Geez, DQ is busting out five new blizzard flavors in the span of 3 months? That's pretty cool right, especially considering that the last 3 three new blizzards I tried were all pretty meh. Anyway, I've got four options to try, but I thinking I'm going to go with the brandy new August blizzard of the month...

Dairy Queen Caramel Apple Cheesecake Blizzard

sweet caramel apple topping swirled with cheesecake pieces in vanilla softserve

Muddy Bites Salted Caramel Shortbread Cookie Cones

[New for 2026] Why yes, I do have one more Muddy Bites review for you that has been in the cabinet for several weeks.... actually should probably say months now..... let's open a bag of....

Muddy Bites Salted Caramel Shortbread Cookie Cones

(buttery cookie cone filled with salted caramel)

Ben & Jerry’s Honey Graham Latte Ice Cream

[New for Spring 2026] No, coffee ice cream is not my thing, but when you put honey graham in the name, I couldn't help but grab a pint of....

Ben & Jerry’s Honey Graham Latte Ice Cream

caramel coffee ice cream with honey graham cracker swirls & crunchy cinnamon swirls

Emerald Brown Butter Irish Ice Cream

[New for 2025] Those new FatBoy pops werent the only thing I brought home from Shaw's the other week. See, I stumbled across the seven pint line up of Emerald Irish Ice Cream which is made with Irish milk, cream, and eggs. These pints debuted just last year and come in Atlantic Sea Salt, Salted Caramel, Chocolate Salted Caramel, Irish Cream, Irish Whiskey, Vanilla Bean, and... 

Emerald Brown Butter Irish Ice Cream

"a creamy blend of toffee and butter"

Ben & Jerry's Caramel Blondie Ice Cream Bars

[New for Early 2026] I don't usually get my ice cream from Market Basket because their stuff is usually freezerburned (like the new Entenmann's flavor from Turkey Hill). That said, when I walked by these, I wasn't about to not bring them home.

Ben & Jerry's Caramel Blondie Ice Cream Bars

caramel ice cream with blondie brownies & salted caramel swirls, dipped in a white chocolate coating with cookie pieces

Ice Cream Factory Gooey Butter Cake

Remember last year when I asked "Is the Ice Cream Factory good?", well, I finally have an answer for you after finding this 3/4 pint buried in my basement freezer. When I went to grab one of the new Ben & Jerry's sundae pints from that freezer, I suddenly got the urge for...

Ice Cream Factory Gooey Butter Cake Ice Cream

buttery cream cheese ice cream with gooey butter cake caramel & butterscotch

FatBoy Waffle Cone Ice Cream Sandwich Pops

[New for Early 2026] So I hit several stores this weekend hoping to find the new Ben & Jerry's Sundae pints. I didn't find them, but I am very happy and excited to report that I did find the brandy new....

FatBoy Waffle Cone Ice Cream Sandwich Pops

vanilla ice cream sandwich with caramel swirl dipped in chocolate coating and rolled in waffle cone pieces

News: Muddy Bites Cookie Cone Snacks

[New for 2026] I was checking a few Muddy Bites facts when I accidentally stumbled across the Target listings for a new product variation from Muddy Bites. Get ready to munch on....

Muddy Bites Cookie Cone Snacks

(images courtesy of target website)

Hazelnut Cocoa Shortbread is a buttery cookie filled with chocolate hazelnut spread. There are also toasted hazelnuts in the mix.

Salted Caramel Shortbread is a buttery cookie filled with salted caramel.

One fun fact is that these say "Product of Germany" on the back.

Are you interested at $5.49 for a 3.5oz bag? I'm not sure if they are anywhere but Target yet.

Ben & Jerry's Salted Caramel Brownie Topped Ice Cream

[New for 2021] It's weird that I haven't reviewed a topped flavor in forever, but then I remembered that the new sundae flavors came out this year. Also, I do still pick up the strawberry topped tart now and again when I want something really sweet. Anyway, let's finally review...

Ben & Jerry's Salted Caramel Brownie Topped Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with salted caramel swirls & fudge brownies topped with caramel cups & chocolatey ganache

DQ Caramel Toffee Cookie Blizzard

[New for Fall 2025]  We've been putting most of our energy in to trying all of the cool local places in Worcester County (and beyond), but there is a new blizzard on the menu, so let's order a....

Dairy Queen Caramel Toffee Cookie Blizzard

vanilla softserve blended with chewy cookie pieces, buttery toffee and golden caramel

New City Microcreamery Tres Leche Ice Cream

Almost 8 years ago, my in-laws surprised me with an ice cream pie from New City Microcreamery (review here). The plan was to visit one of their scoop shops, but we never did. At some point, their faux pints started showing up in stores, and still I did not try them (we'll blame location). Well, after all this time, I finally decided to try "the best in the world". That's a pretty bold statement...

New City Microcreamery Tres Leche Ice Cream

cream cheese ice cream soaked vanilla cookies with dolce de leche swirl

Ben & Jerry's Fudgy Flan Ice Cream

[New for Mid 2025] When I ran to Walmart for a few things before a day trip on Monday, I never expected to see something new. Not only is it new, but it maybe it'll even be different enough to get your attention. Lets dive in to....

Ben & Jerry's Fudgy Flan Ice Cream

burnt caramel ice cream with fudge brownies & pastry cream swirls

McConnell's Sweet Cream Caramel Brownie Ice Cream

I know my street cred has always been lacking a proper pint of the well regarded McConnell's in the mix, but that ends today! I splurged on an $8 pint from Wegman's so that I could test my Swell Ice Cream Chiller. Well, it brought the pint home safe and sound. Time to try....

McConnell's Sweet Cream Caramel Brownie Ice Cream

vanilla spiked sweet cream ice cream with salted caramel and brownies

Wendy's Caramel Vanilla Frosty Swirl

[New for April 2025] I know I've gotten terrible with keeping up with fast food releases, but the opportunity arose to check out the new frosty swirl lineup, so I grabbed...

Wendy's Caramel Vanilla Frosty Swirl

vanilla frosty swirled with caramel

Fat Boy Churro Sandwich

[New for 2025] ...whoa, I just wrote "New for 2025".... crazy....  but yeah, I'm actually pretty stoked to be ice cream hunting this year. The last few years have been pretty boring, and I know I'm not going to enjoy everything headed our way, but it just feels more....   normal? We're supposed to get wound up for a new ice cream season in January. It's kind of a lost tradition. So, knowing that my local Shaw's had already started clearing shelf space, I ran to see what I could find early in the morning, and yeah, I found one of the things that I was most excited for!

Fat Boy Cinnamon Churro Sandwich

vanilla ice cream with a sea salt caramel core sandwiched between two cinnamon churro cookies

Tillamook Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

[New for Dec 2024] More new Tillamook! Woohoo! I'm pretty sure that I'm going to continue to eat a lot of Tillamook ice cream in 2025. Let's scoop in to....

Tillamook Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

salted vanilla ice cream with chocolaty covered pretzel bits and a ribbon of salted caramel

Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge

[New for 1994] Whenever there is a big sale on Ben & Jerry's, I like to treat myself to a pint or two of the good stuff. I might pick up one of my current favorites, or I might pick up something that I haven't had in forever so that I can take new pictures and add a quick update to an old review (here is a random example). Well when I picked up this pint well over a month ago, I didn't realize that I had never had it on the blog before... like, seriously, how has this 30 year old ice cream not been on the blog?

Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with swirls of caramel & fudge

Friendly's Caramel Waffle Cone Ice Cream Bars

[For 2024-2025] To be honest, based on Friendly's current lineup, I'm not expecting much from these bars. Last year's ice cream bars were ok, but not so good that they would force me to try these... but I do need me a mowing snack, so let's crack open a box of....

Friendly's Caramel Waffle Cone Ice Cream Bars

caramel ice cream, caramel flavored swirl, and chocolatey waffle cone pieces

Edy's Churro Caramel Crossroads Ice Cream

[New for Early 2023] Oh Edy's (Dreyer's), how little you effect my life these days. It's just hard to keep them in mind when I just don't see them that much now, and if I do, it's usually just a handful of standard flavors. The only thing really going on with them is the rocky road collection, and I don't see much of that around here. However, Market Basket does have them from time to time, so, let's take a scoop of...

Edy's / Dreyer's Churro Caramel Crossroads Ice Cream

caramel ice cream - churro pieces - fudge swirls