More Dr. Bombay Flavors?

[New for Mid 2025] I can't believe I'm saying this, but two more Dr. Bombay flavors will be showing up at your local Walmart! I don't know who is buying these, but someone is!

credit: Dr. Bombay / Walmart

Sticky Caramel Apple is green apple sherbet and caramel ice cream with crunchy peanuts and salted caramel swirls.

Long Beach Fruit Cart is mango sherbet and coconut ice cream with pineapple pieces and spiced mango swirls.

Are you interested by either of these at four bucks a pint? Maybe you've seen them? I'll admit that they are certainly creative sounding, but with their track record, it's still not enough to bring me back in the Dr. Bombay fold. What do you think?

Tillamook Apple Crisp Ice Cream

[New for Late 2024] While Market32 has been supplying us with all of our Tillamook Holiday Sugar Cookie needs, it was Market Basket that hooked me up with the new hotness. That's right, it's time to scoop in to...

Tillamook Apple Crisp Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with crisp apples and baked oatmeal streusel pieces

Van Leeuwen: Cake vs Pie

I'm not sure what I'm in the mood for right now, so let's bring back that age old question of "what's better, cake or pie?" The question is also an excuse to clean up the freezer!

Van Leeuwen Limoncello Ice Cream

Van Leeuwen Apple Pie Ice Cream

WisePies Pizza Make-A-Wish WishPies

[New for Late 2022] I was just going to take a picture of these when I saw them, but then I checked the nutrition and ingredient and thought "yeah, that's gonna be a Saturday afternoon snack". These Walmart exclusive pies are $6.98 a piece with a dollar of that going to the Make a Wish foundation (full press release here). Now, let's cook ourselves up a....

WisePies Cinnamon Apple Drizzle Dessert Pizza WishPies

diced apples in cinnamon and sugar sauce

atop a stone-fired, cinnamon-infused crust

Hannaford Cinnamon Swirl Apple Pie Ice Cream

[New for 2021?] During a rogue trip to Hannaford, I spotted something that I hadn't seen before. Admittedly, I was a little hesitant to purchase it because I've been disappointed by apple flavors before, I but I decided to give in and buy....

Hannaford Cinnamon Swirl Apple Pie Ice Cream

apple pie ice cream with cinnamon swirl

Breyers Caramel Apple Pie Layered Dessert

[Limited Edition for Fall 2020] Yay! It's another Breyer's Flavor! ...ha ha, fooled ya, I'm not actually excited... fine, you knew I wasn't actually excited, but keep reading for some stupid fun.

Breyers Caramel Apple Pie Layered Dessert

vanilla with apples between two layers of caramel with shortbread pie crust pieces

Friendly's I Cannot Tell a Lie Cherry Pie Ice Cream

[Limited Edition for Early 2020] Pickings are slim when you only go to the grocery store once a week, and my local walmart has been consistently wiped out. However, those stocking up seem a little hesitant to grab something new which means I get to try....

Friendly's I Cannot Tell a Lie Cherry Pie Ice Cream

sweet cream ice cream, pie crust pieces and tart cherry swirl

So Delicious Oatmilk Frozen Dessert

[New for 2019] Guess what? There's not one, but two oat milk ice creams coming out this year. This makes me happy because my son is quite partial to his vanilla oat milk so I think this might actually be something he enjoys. Oh, also, we're cheating and trying two of the flavors at once. There is a third flavor, peanut butter & raspberry, but for safety we left that one at the store.

So Delicious Oatmilk Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert

Oatmeal Cookie & Caramel Apple Crumble

Whole Foods Apple Pie Ice Cream Bars and the Nosh Show Episode 89

[New for Fall 2016] Hello Nosh Show listeners! Episode 89 is live and when you get to the end, I mention a product that hadn't won me over just yet. As everyday items continue their assimilation into the worlds of pumpkin and apple (before an explosion of peppermint products hit us), it's nice to see apple and not just pumpkin invading the freezer aisle.

Whole Foods 365 Apple Pie Ice Cream Bars

Edy's Washington Apple Pie Ice Cream

[New for early 2016] I haven't had the urge to try any more of the new slow churned Edy's (Dreyer's) state inspired flavors but Cumberland Farms amazing apple pie ice cream had such an amazing flavor that I think I'm finally ready to dig in to....

Edy's Slow Churned Washington Apple Pie Ice Cream

cinnamon light ice cream with 100% washington apples and pie pieces

Cumberland Farms Amazing Apple Pie Ice Cream

When I picked up Cumberland Farms latest Ultimate scoop flavor, I used their 2 for $7 promotion to pick up a second pint as well. School time means fall time, so I think something seasonal is in order.

Cumberland Farms Amazing Apple Pie Ice Cream

cinnamon flavored ice cream with caramel ripple,
apple chunks & bits of pie crust

Coolhaus Renzo Apple Pie-Ano Ice Cream Sandwich

[By Nick] It's October 1st which to me means it's officially apple picking season! Oh how I love living in Upstate, NY with all of our apple orchards. If you've never bitten into a freshly picked apple, you haven't lived. Now while this Coolhaus sandwich can't be picked from a tree, you can pick it straight from a freezer near you like I did at the Niskayuna Co-op.

Coolhaus Renzo Apple Pie-Ano Ice Cream Sandwich

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies & Baked Apple Ice Cream

Dairy Queen Apple Pie Blizzard The September 2014 DQ Blizzard of the Month

[New for 2014] Hello! we interrupt the final post of Nick week to let you know that Dairy Queen has gone and given us an early fall surprise this weekend. Remember how I always say that the new Grill 'n Chill is awesome about being on time with new blizzards? Well, we were going to wrap up our family Saturday stuff with the Chips Ahoy blizzard when my wife goes "APPLE PIE BLIZZARD!". Wait, WHAT?? Sure enough, I look over and in the window is the new Apple Pie Blizzard and get this, the excellent Pumpkin Pie blizzard is back already!! I'm usually the first to complain about fall flavors coming in to early but I'm so stoked right now. Do I try Chips Ahoy again or do I go Apple pie? Oh man, what to pick??

DQ Apple Pie Blizzard

Adirondack Creamery Caramel Apple Ice Cream

[By Nick] In my last review, I mentioned I can't stand applesauce (Dubba's Note: HEATHEN!). However, I absolutely love a fresh, crisp apple. Living in Upstate, NY, nothing quite says fall like a freshly picked apple from a local orchard. Apples are basically what pumpkin spice is to the rest of the world around this time. Apple cider donuts are easily one of my favorite treats around this time but if anything tops those, it has to be a caramel apple. Sure you can get them at most fairs during the summer but the ones I can get locally in the fall are far superior.

So why did I give you this back story? Well, I've been meaning to try Adirondack Creamery for a while now and knew they came out with a Caramel Apple flavor last year that is exclusive to the NY Metropolitan at the Whole Foods in Brooklyn as well as Adams Fairacre Farms in the Mid-Hudson Valley. I live nowhere close to either of those places so when I spotted this flavor at the Niskayuna Co-op I jumped right on it. I have no idea how they got their hands on it but I'm not complaining.

Talenti Caramel Apple Pie Gelato #29

[New for 2014] Is winter over yet? I mean, how many commutes can be messed up in a single season? Granted I'll take a terrible 3 hour ride home over a few days of power loss, but this season needs to be done with, the two feet of snow in my yard needs to melt, and spring needs to kick in to action. Uggg. See, the two easy ways back to my house were both bogged down by the slippery ride home on Wednesday, so I took the long way, stopped in to Market Basket, and then nearly jumped for joy when I saw this.

Talenti Caramel Apple Pie Gelato

Cinnamon gelato with apples, flaky pie crust and a caramel swirl

Breyers Apple Cinnamon Crumble FDD

Ok, you all know I'm distrustful of Breyers and their so called "more desirable" frozen dairy desserts, but several our fellow ice cream buddies have said this one is good, so here goes.

Breyers Apple Cinnamon Crumble Frozen Dairy Dessert

Apple flavor with an apple cinnamon swirl and pie crust pieces

The Other JC Pie Pops : Chocolate Silk, Strawberry Cream, and Caramel Apple Crumble

Guess what? This is our 900th review post! Not just 900 posts, but 900 review posts! Now considering the fact that just 4 or 5 posts are re-reviews, and then factoring in that dozens of posts (like fights) cover multiple products means that we've covered well over 900 unique frozen products on this blog! That also means we're just a stone's throw away from hitting a 1000! Not every review is a huge dissertation, but sometimes a half decent or so-so treat only deserves a couple of pics and a few choice words. Who knows what the next review will be, but at least you can count on the fact that it won't be a repeat!

To celebrate our achievement, I've got a TRIPLE review for you guys. I was blown away by my first JC pie pop experience and so I couldn't wait to tear into their other three flavors. So, without further ado, it's time to get hungry.

JC's Chocolate Silk Pie Pop

Creamy French Silk blanketed by a milk chocolate and while chocolate sugar cookie crust

Front Porch County Fair Fried Apple Pie Ice Cream

[New for 2013] Time to try another flavor from our free shipment of new Front Porch ice cream pints. Now Front Porch premium Carolina churned ice cream is new to to the market as of last year, but it's made by the fine folks of Mooresville Ice Cream who have been around since 1924.

This is Front Porch County Fair Fried Apple Pie ice cream. It's "spiced apple ice cream with an apple swirl and pieces of cinnamon sugar shortbread".  I always get excited when cinnamon is involved.

Perry's Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream and NEW Apple Pie Ice Cream

Perry's seems like a cool company with some cool flavors, but I'm relegated to a very tiny selection of their lineup that is served up by the only Wegman's in Mass. Thankfully for me, I was pleasantly surprised when Perry's sent over an email asking if I wanted some free samples of their fall flavors. I said yes in a heartbeat and patiently waited for my delivery.

Behold Perry's Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream and their new Apple Pie Ice Cream (which was discontinued a few years later). Nothing says fall like Pumpkins and Apples. I'm digging the black limited edition packaging. I mean, besides Breyers, who else rocks black?

Hubigs Apple Pie Ice Cream from New Orleans Ice Cream Company

Oh geez, I've gone and got myself backlogged again. I know I did the Wonka reviews a little too close together (partially because of my refusal to put them all in one post), so I wanted to take my time with the New Orleans Ice Cream reviews. It's good stuff and seems deserving of some better spacing as they begin their nationwide rollout. Problem is, now I feel like I'm behind the 8-apple ball.

This is Hubigs Apple Pie Ice Cream from New Orleans ice cream. Now Hubigs isn't some funky spice or cooking style, it's a New Orleans bakery institution that is beloved by many. Unfortunately tragedy struck early Friday morning,  July 27th, 2012. The bakery was destroyed by fire. It was a sad day for the community. Hubigs was knocked out for four months after Katrina yet went on to regularly feed the overworked local police and firefighters with unsold pies during the recovery (You can read more here). I wish them the best in their recovery efforts and if you are interested, the best way to help right now is to keep Hubig's in your thoughts, prayers, tweets, newsfeeds, and shirt closet. Until they are back on their feet, they can't make anymore of this ice cream.