Tillamook Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

[New for Dec 2024] More new Tillamook! Woohoo! I'm pretty sure that I'm going to continue to eat a lot of Tillamook ice cream in 2025. Let's scoop in to....

Tillamook Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

salted vanilla ice cream with chocolaty covered pretzel bits and a ribbon of salted caramel

Ben & Jerry's Churn Out the Vote Ice Cream

[New for Aug 2024] Well looky what I found at Walmart today! [HA! The clouds say VOTE!]

Ben & Jerry's Churn Out the Vote Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with pretzel swirls, fudge chips & swirls of chocolate mousse

Ben & Jerry's Impretzively Fudged Ice Cream

[New for Early 2024] There are three new Ben & Jerry's flavors on (some) shelves now. There is the fun sounding, limited batch Marshmallow Sky (not to be confused with Marshmallow Moon) and then at Hannaford, I found the tasty sounding PB S'mores and....

Ben & Jerry's Impretzively Fudged Ice Cream

chocolate ice cream with fudge-covered pretzel pieces & pretzel swirls

Have you tried Graeter's Midnight Snack?

[New for 2022] I was at Wegman's when I spied this wonderful sounding flavor.

Graeter's Midnight Snack Ice Cream

chocolate covered pretzels, mini peanut butter cups,

and brownies in malt ice cream

Man I need to try this one. Graeter's quality + brownies + pretzels + peanut cups + a fun malt base? Yes please on all counts. Can anyone confirm how tasty this one is?

So this was their "Mystery Flavor" for 2022 (announcement is here), but I don't see a mystery flavor for 2023. Instead I see talk of five limited edition "bonus flavors" for the year. First came Dough'licious, then Hot Honey Crunch, and now they've announced Lemon Meringue Pie. It's tart lemon candies and crunchy pie crust pieces in a lemon marshmallow ice cream. Wow, that sounds fun! If anyone tries any of these, please share your thoughts. Thanks!

Ice Cream Machine Co

We were hanging around northeast Rhode Island when we decided to grab ice cream for lunch (because ice cream). We've been trying to explore more local places, so we decided to give the Ice Cream Machine Company in Cumberland, RI a try. Wanting something fancy and filling to try, we decided to give their Blondie Brownie sundaes a try (cost was $7.95 a piece).

Gifford's Cone-y Pretzel Whirl Ice Cream

[New for 2022] For the first time in a very long time, the Mrs. and I went out for sundaes yesterday. Now technically we stopped at Sonic first, but after reading their extremely boring menu, we started searching around for something a bit more worthy of our time. Well, we came upon Moose Trackers in Scituate, RI. It's a fun little place that popped up in 2020 and they happen to have Gifford's two news flavors: Blue Monstah Cookie and....

Gifford's Cone-y Pretzel Whirl Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with chocolate covered waffle cone pieces and pretzel swirl

Edy's Salted Caramel Pretzel Path Ice Cream

[New for early 2021] Released as part of of their Rocky Road Collection, today's review marks the first Edy's/Nestle review in almost 3 years! I don't know about you, but I just don't see Edy's that much anymore, and when I do, it's rarely a member of the six part rocky road collection.

Edy's Salted Caramel Pretzel Path Ice Cream

caramel ice cream with fudge swirls,

 chocolatey covered pretzel pieces and chocolatey covered toffee

Talenti Caramel Pretzels Blondie

[New for 2022] After the epic disappointment that was the strawberry margarita pairing, let's try again with a flavor that has one of my favorite words in the name. That's right, Talenti has put out another pretzel flavor and I am pretty stoked to try....

Talenti Caramel Pretzels Blondie Gelato Pairing #83

sea salt caramel gelato paired with

salted pretzel gelato with blondie pieces

Breyers Chocolate Pretzel Swirl

[New for 2021] On January 5th, Unilever announced new products across all their product lines including 3 new flavors in the regular Breyers line up. We'll be getting Coconut Fudge, Double Chocolate Brownie Batter and...

Breyers Chocolate Pretzel Swirl Frozen Dairy Dessert

chocolate with a crushed, salted pretzel swirl and chocolatey chips

Talenti Chocolate Pretzel Gelato Layers

[New for 2021] Everyone remembers that I love pretzels right? I spent the first couple decades of my life consuming vast quantities of them. I may be down to a handful every day or two, but I still think very highly of them. Let's see if Talenti can do them justice here.

Talenti Chocolate Pretzel Gelato Layers #74

salted pretzel gelato, chocolatey waffle cone pieces,

salted pretzel sauce, vanilla gelato, chocolate flakes

Ben & Jerry's Netflix & Chilll'd Ice Cream

[New for 2020] Positive or negative... positive or negative? Fine, I'll be negative and say it. I was sad I didn't get to go to the fancy schmancy event that B&J put on for this new Netflix flavor. I understand that the next generation of social media peeps is where it's at, but I'm human, just like everyone else, and I have feelings. That said, it doesn't stop me from wanting to try their new flavor because it sounds like an easy win.

Ben & Jerry's Netflix & Chilll'd Ice Cream

peanut butter ice cream
with sweet & salty pretzel swirls & fudge brownies

Tasty Strawberry Pretzel Cheesecake Crunch

[New for Fall 2019] Tasty Ice Cream.... the fairly unloved offspring of Buzzfeed. What can I say about it? Well, one, no one came to their defense on my instagram page, but could it really be that bad? Will I feel gipped after paying $4.99 for just 14 oz of ice cream? Let's find out!

Tasty Strawberry Pretzel Cheesecake Crunch Ice Cream

cheesecake ice cream with strawberry swirls,
strawberry flavoring coating pretzels, and a graham cracker swirl

Serendipity Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

[New for Fall 2019, faded away in 2024] There are three new flavors from Serendipity that should be hitting your store shelves soon. I was fortunate enough to receive free samples so let's jump in to the one that got my attention (because it has "pretzel" in the name!).

Serendipity Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with chocolatey covered pretzel bits
and salty caramel swirl

Ben & Jerry's Candy Bar Pie Pint Slice

[New for 2019, discontinued] Do you miss Ben & Jerry's Candy Bar Pie flavor? It was a scoop shop flavor in 2013 and then in limited batch pints in 2014, but then it left us sadly. Well, it's time for a comeback in the form of a pint slice (there is also the new amaze-mint pint slice). I can't imagine it's bad, I really just wonder how good it will be.

Ben & Jerry's Candy Bar Pie Pint Slice

peanut butter ice cream bars with fudge flakes & a salty pretzel fusion,
covered in a dark chocolatey coating

Perry's Elf Trash Ice Cream

[New for late 2018] Do you have a favorite Holiday flavor? Peppermint Stick is everywhere, and several companies offer Eggnog as well, but how about something more silly? Well, I went to Wegman's at lunch and ran in to....

Perry's Elf Trash Ice Cream

white chocolate ice cream with red and green fudge candies,
fudge covered pretzels, fudge covered peanuts, and praline peanuts

Big Gay Ice Cream - American Globs

[New for 2017] I wasn't really sure in what order I would be trying all the Big Gay ice cream flavors, but let's just say that I've kept an eye on both prices and the dates on the pints and this one had just been put on the store shelf, plus it has my favorite crunchy snack: pretzels.

Big Gay Ice Cream - American Globs

malted sweet cream ice cream with fudge-covered salted pretzel balls,
fudge-covered pretzel pieces & a fudge swirl

Ben & Jerry’s Glampfire Trail Mix Ice Cream

[By Nick, New for 2018, Target Exclusive] I sent Dubba these photos a couple of months ago when this flavor was first released. I was one of the first to find it and was so excited to be one of the first to review it. I definitely dropped the ball on this one. Ahhh life, what can you do? Better late than never, I suppose. So let’s skip the jokes about glamping and go straight into the review.

Ben & Jerry’s Glampfire Trail Mix Ice Cream

Chocolate Ice Cream with Crunchy Pretzel Swirls,
Marshmallow Swirls & Fudge Covered Almonds

Cumberland Farms Ultimate Scoop Chocolate Treat Trail Mix Twist Ice Cream

[New for 2016] Yeah, I broke my every other day posting schedule again, sorry about that. It's been tough these last few weeks as there's just so little to choose from, life is in flux as school mode kicks back in, and allergies are beating me up. It's just one of those Wednesdays that feels like a Thursday even though it's kind of like a Tuesday and oh my brain is spinning too fast and I need ice cream. Wait, I know, I'll hit up Cumberland Farms and grab something cheap.

Cumberland Farms Chocolate Treat Trail Mix Twist Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with a fudge swirl,
loaded with chocolate-dipped almonds, peanuts, pretzels and raisins,
plus candy coated chocolate - everybody's trail-mix favorites!

Talenti Peanut Butter Pretzel Gelato #42

[New for 2016, retired] I ran in to the store this morning with low expectations, but then I spied *5* new Talenti flavors. The 2016 season is finally starting to kick in! I did hesitate for a moment as I decided which pint I should buy, but let's be honest, it wasn't that hard for me to pick...

Talenti Peanut Butter Pretzel Gelato #42

peanut butter gelato with a peanut butter swirl
and chocolate covered pretzel balls

Perry's One Buffalo Ice Cream

[New to quarts in 2016] On October 8th of 2015, Perry's announced a new flavor that is an ode to their beloved city of Buffalo. At first is was only available at a couple of arenas, but as part of Perry's rebranding of their quart and pint offerings, you can now get....

Perry's One Buffalo Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream with sea salt caramel swirls, sponge candy pieces, and fudge-coated pretzels