New City Microcreamery Tres Leche Ice Cream

Almost 8 years ago, my in-laws surprised me with an ice cream pie from New City Microcreamery (review here). The plan was to visit one of their scoop shops, but we never did. At some point, their faux pints started showing up in stores, and still I did not try them (we'll blame location). Well, after all this time, I finally decided to try "the best in the world". That's a pretty bold statement...

New City Microcreamery Tres Leche Ice Cream

cream cheese ice cream soaked vanilla cookies with dolce de leche swirl

Ben & Jerry's Fudgy Flan Ice Cream

[New for Mid 2025] When I ran to Walmart for a few things before a day trip on Monday, I never expected to see something new. Not only is it new, but it maybe it'll even be different enough to get your attention. Lets dive in to....

Ben & Jerry's Fudgy Flan Ice Cream

burnt caramel ice cream with fudge brownies & pastry cream swirls

7-Eleven Ice Cream - Birthday Cake and Brookie Dough

Oh my gosh, it's been **6 years** since I've reviewed a pint of 7/11 ice cream! See, the downside of working from home is that you lose a lot of daily diversity in your life. For example, I can't stop at 7/11 on the way to work anymore. However, I was returning from an early morning drive when I passed by one that doesn't usually have a very good selection, but they did have a 2 for $10 sale. They had pints of strawberry banana and banana cream pie (sorry, but no thank you), and they also had...

Seven Select Birthday Cake Ice Cream

Seven Select Brookie Dough Ice Cream

McConnell's Sweet Cream Caramel Brownie Ice Cream

I know my street cred has always been lacking a proper pint of the well regarded McConnell's in the mix, but that ends today! I splurged on an $8 pint from Wegman's so that I could test my Swell Ice Cream Chiller. Well, it brought the pint home safe and sound. Time to try....

McConnell's Sweet Cream Caramel Brownie Ice Cream

vanilla spiked sweet cream ice cream with salted caramel and brownies

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Cake Ice Cream

[New for 2024] I bought this because it feels like forever since I've had Van Leeuwen in the freezer. Also, "ice cream cake".

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream Cake Ice Cream

birthday cake ice cream with dark chocolate cream-filled cookies and swirls of blue frosting

Friendly's Jonas Brothers 20th Anniversary Ice Cream

[New for 2025] When I went to see if Friendly's was going to deliver something new this year, I really wasn't expecting a limited edition Jonas Brothers inspired flavor to be sitting at the top of the page. Apparently they've been fans of Friendly's since they were kids. You know I don't really do coffee ice cream, but let's take some scoops of....

Friendly's Jonas Brothers 20th Anniversary Ice Cream

coffee cookie crumble, chocolate marshmallow, and vanilla

Kellogg's Froot Loops Ice Cream

[New for Early 2025] Yes, I gave in and tried another cereal flavor. I didn't have super high hopes, but I thought maybe things would turn out differently this time.... Nope. Instead, this confirmed my feelings about the cereal inspired line up and this will probably be the last of the cereal flavors that I review (though I did just see a video saying that the apple jacks flavor was the best of the bunch, which I can see making sense. anyway...).

Kellogg's Froot Loops Ice Cream

cereal milk-flavored ice cream blended with Kellogg's froot loops cereal pieces

Haagen-Dazs Matcha Green Tea

This one had been in the freezer forever, but I did finally eat it, and then I waited a few more months to post the review. Sorry about that, but I can't imagine you were holding your breath for this review anyway hehehe.

Haagen-Dazs Matcha Green Tea Ice Cream

Blue Bunny Soft Churro

[New for Early 2025] I know I said I wouldn't run to try this one, especially since coconut oil is in the mix and I'm afraid it will make things worse here, but it was on sale, so I bought....

Blue Bunny Soft Churro

cinnamon soft frozen dairy dessert with shortbread pieces

Baskin-Robbins Cookie Monster Ice Cream

[New for 2025] When I bought this next flavor, I bought it because it was blue, not because I was sure it was new. I just wanted it, plain and simple. I'm glad I did, because it's now my favorite of the at home flavors.

Baskin-Robbins (at home) Cookie Monster Ice Cream

sweet cream ice cream with chocolate sandwich cookie pieces, chocolate chip cookie pieces & cookie dough batter flavored swirls

Ben & Jerry's Strawberries & Cream Scoop-apoolza

[New for Early 2025] I mentioned these big faux quarts not making a ton of sense, but it's still Ben & Jerry's, so let's at least try one of them. I think we'll start with....

Ben & Jerry's Strawberries & Cream Scoop-apalooza

sweet cream ice cream with strawberry swirls.

Kellogg's Frosted Flakes Ice Cream

[New for Early 2025] So I mentioned on the Rice Krispies Treat review that I had opened both (faux) pints and decided that I needed to try RKT first. Well, we saw how that went. Now it's a few hours later (literally, not figuratively) and I need to try this one to see if I made the right choice.

Kellogg's Frosted Flakes Ice Cream

cereal milk flavored ice cream blended with Frosted Flakes

Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats Ice Cream

[New for 2025] There are a bunch of Kellogg's pints coming at us, but to be sensible, I only brought two home. I opened both Frosted Flakes and this one, but after doing a quick sniff test, I decided that this one needed scooping first. Let's dive in to....

Kellogg's Rice Krispies Treats Ice Cream

marshmallow flavored ice cream swirled with marshmallow and marshmallow flavored coated rice crisps.

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Covered Strawberry

[New for Early 2025] I was a little concerned that this next flavor appeared to be a Valentine's flavor and yet was seemingly absent from store shelves on Valentine's day. Well, I was at Walmart this morning (2/27) when I found a dented pint sitting amongst all the other non-new flavors. Thankfully I spied one more pint hiding far behind it, and that one wasn't dented. Let's finally dive in to a flavor that should be right up my alley.

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Covered Strawberry Ice Cream

strawberry ice cream with a strawberry jam swirl & fudge flakes

Kellogg's Ice Cream

[New for Early 2025] I stumbled on @eat_yums instagram post about coming across *5* cereal inspired ice creams at Safeway! Oh, I see The Impulsive Buy has reported them at Shaw's as well! I love ice cream for breakfast and I love mixing ice cream and cereal, so these are right up my alley. I hope they are good!

all images belong to WK Kellogg Co

Talenti Chocolate Chip Cookie Batter

[New for Early 2025] Yes, I gave in and tried Snickerdoodle first, and it's a solid flavor, but let's see if this one cant bring the thunder.

Talenti Chocolate Chip Cookie Batter Bakery Collection Gelato Layers

chocolate chip cookie gelato - shortbread cookies - cookie batter - vanilla gelato - chocolate cookies

Talenti Snickerdoodle Cookie

[New for Early 2025] I was running through Stop & Shop when I found two of the new bakery collection lineup. They didn't have Tiramisu, but they did have chocolate chip cookie batter and....

Talenti Snickerdoodle Cookie Bakery Collection Gelato Layers

snickerdoodle cookie gelato - cinnamon cookies - snickerdoodle cookie batter - vanilla gelato - cinnamon cookie pieces

Haagen-Dazs Salted Brown Butter Cookie

[New for 2025] I went to Hannaford with the mild hope of finding something new. Well, I came home with one of the new Ben & Jerry's Sundae flavors and also....

Haagen-Dazs Salted Brown Butter Cookie Ice Cream

brown butter ice cream with milk chocolaty chips and cookie pieces with a touch of salt

Friendly's Salted Vanilla Fudge Ice Cream

[New for 2025] More new stuff already? Yup! I actually bought this before the churro stuff but only because I thought I would need it to pass the time until the good stuff came out.

Friendly's Salted Vanilla Fudge Ice Cream

salted vanilla ice cream with fudge pieces and a fudge swirl

Tillamook Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

[New for Dec 2024] More new Tillamook! Woohoo! I'm pretty sure that I'm going to continue to eat a lot of Tillamook ice cream in 2025. Let's scoop in to....

Tillamook Salty Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream

salted vanilla ice cream with chocolaty covered pretzel bits and a ribbon of salted caramel