Tuesday, November 26, 2013

Ben & Jerry's Mississippi Mud Pie Ice Cream

[New for 2013] Look, I'll admit it, even I'm confused as to why a new limited batch is coming out so late in the year. I mean, in a month I would say it's an early 2014 surprise, or if it was holiday themed, that would make sense too, but this seems so out of the blue. I mean, Walmart already has the exclusive flavors of Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup (review) and Cotton Candy (review), so yeah, them getting Mississippi Mud Pie as a third exclusive flavor in one year is kind of a big deal.

Ben & Jerry's Mississippi Mud Pie Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream & Vanilla Ice Cream 
with Chocolate Cake Pieces & a Chocolate Mousse Swirl

There's an interesting smell coming off of this one, it must be the mousse!

Cool! I'm digging the color scheme and the cake bits look promising.

Ok, I take my first few bites and I'm already hooked. Not only is there a mousse swirl, but I'm thinking this pint might have a great overall mousse flavor. Oh this one might be awesome (don't forget, I am a chocolate fiend).

Yup, definitely liking this one, especially when I hit the mousse swirl. The flavor is varying based on how much of each component I get. When you get a fair amount of vanilla, it's almost got a hoodsie cup vibe to it which adds a bit of fun to the pint. Oh, I could plow through this pint, but I'm trying to take my time.... really I am.

The flavor variety is definitely keeping me on my toes. It's just a really nice rich milk chocolate flavor overall. Ahhh, perfectly dialed in on the chocolate on some bites, then this neat modified flavoring on the other bites. So often I get bored when Ben & Jerry's swirls their vanilla with other flavors because it becomes a big muted... thing, but they've done something different here and it totally keeps you hooked.

If you're curious, I haven't hit any large puddles of mousse. Instead my pint consists of thin swirls that are enhancing the flavor here and there. Since it's chocolate on chocolate, we're talking about the flavors enhancing each other rather than any kind of stark contrast.

Ok, I haven't seen a ton of cake bites but to be honest I don't really care right now. They seem tasty enough, plus they are nice and soft, but their frequency.... actually, wow, that cake bit really stood out (in a good way). There's a little something extra in the cake bits, but I just can't put my finger on it. A little extra flavor hook if you get them alone. Another nice touch.

Oops, over half the pint is gone and I've now consumed all my saturated fat for the day.

I really need to say this again. All too often the vanilla seems to dull the overall flavor in these Ben & Jerry's pints, but instead this one delivers the perfect milk chocolate flavor. I'm not sure if I've just had a chocolate shake or a slice of chocolate mousse, but either way, oh am I satisfied.... and thinking I should have bought two pints so I don't have to share this one.

Random Thought: swap the cake bites for their chocolate cookie swirl = chocolate cream pie!

Verdict?  Excellent
Buy Again?  Oh yeah, time to hoard

Nutrition Facts
Serving Size 1/2 cup (102g)
Servings Per Container   4

Amount Per Serving
Calories  270
from Fat  140

% Daily Value*
Total Fat  15g
- Sat Fat 9g
- Trans Fat  0g

Cholesterol  55mg
Sodium  55mg
Total Carbohydrate  28g
- Dietary Fiber   2g
- Sugars  26g

Protein  4g

Vitamin A   8%
Vitamin C   0%
Calcium   10%
Iron   10%


  1. For me, this is such a slap in the face. They discontinued Mud Pie (and Dublin Mudslide before it) just to come out with this Mississippi Mud Pie which does not contain the Irish Cream Liqueur flavor. Ugh!

  2. Oh wow. If anything would drive me to a Wal-Mart on Black Friday, this would be it! Although I do miss the Mud Pie flavor too...it didn't last long. :(

  3. Mud Pie was my all-time #1. Very bummed its gone. The texture of that cookie swirl was so great.

  4. So upset Mississippi Mud was discontinued this is definitely my favorite!!!

  5. HT has mud pie. I think it's [junk] though


*** All comments are moderated ***
Expect a delay before they are posted