Sunday, September 11, 2011

Blue Bunny I Do, I Do Wedding Cake
Ice Cream Review

[New for 2011, discontinued before 2014] For those of you who have been here since the very beginning, you may remember that I use to talk about "my trusted adviser". Before he got his work IM turned off, we were having quite the interesting daily conversations, often covering ice cream. He and his future bride popped up again later as "my roving reporters". Well, I'm happy to say they got married over the summer, woohoo!

This was their (tasty) cake. As many couples do, each layer was a different flavor. So we got a layer of cookies & cream, a Dubba pleasing carrot cake, and then if there was any doubt left in your mind about the coolness of the cake, it was rocking a layer of key lime pie! I love when people spice things up, I really do, but I wonder if any guests were missing the old wedding classic of a white cake with a raspberry swirl?

Blue Bunny to the rescue! (Literally, they sent this as a sample) This is "I Do, I Do Wedding Cake" and it's sweet butter cream frosting flavored ice cream with white cake pieces and ribbons of raspberry sauce.

Oh man, do you see all those cake pieces? I was so giddy that I (inadvertently) scooped them all into my wife's bowl, not realizing they weren't as plentiful further down. Don't get me wrong, there are still some, and they are tasty and fresh just like in the other Duff Goldman flavors, you just have to be careful how you divy them up.

You see this mighty swirl before you? Well, it goes with the massive cake flavor that struck me from the very first bite. This one is not for the timid. This is a bold flavor and it will demand your attention whether you want to give it or not. This one is strong, this one is sweet, and for some strange reason, I keep thinking I taste cream cheese.

I know, I know, I'm not the greatest judge of flavors, but that's how this one hits me. Yes, I get the undeniable cake vibe, it's smacking me across the face yelling "pay attention", but the way it lingers reminds me of many other attempted cheesecake flavored ice creams. Hmmm, maybe that's why my wife likes this one so much!

If you like classic wedding cake (and ice cream), you should like this one. This is one of those flavors where you go "hey, you gotta try this one, it's bold!". If you don't like overly sweet or potent ice creams, this ain't for you. Thanks to Blue Bunny for the sample!

Verdict?  different and potent
Buy Again?  possible (for my wife though)

Final BB - Duff Goldman Rankings:
  1. Triple Chocolate Cake
  2. Strawberry are Forever Shortcake
  3. Caramel Fudge Brownie Sundae (2013)
  4. I Do, I Do Wedding Cake
  5. 24 Karat Carrot Cake (2012)
  6. Red Carpet Red Velvet Cake
Nutrition Facts
Serving Size 1/2 cup (70g)
Servings Per Container 14

Amount Per Serving
Calories 150from Fat 60
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 7g11%
- Sat Fat 4g20%
- Trans Fat 0g
Cholesterol 25mg9%
Sodium 75mg3%
Potassium 115mg3%
Total Carbohydrate 19g6%
- Dietary Fiber 0g0%
- Sugars 16g
Protein 2g5%

Vitamin A 4%Vitamin C 0%
Calcium 8%Iron 0%


  1. I thought this stuff was pretty good. I like the strawberry shortcake variety more though. Maybe just personal preference.

  2. Did blue bunny send u a free sample of strawberries are forever shortcake too. I can't find these 2 flavors any where close to me in ct. Just red velvet cake & triple chocolate cake.

  3. @CAH: mmmmm, strawberry (I concur)

    @Anon: They did send the strawberries are forever, but I'm 90% sure I've seen it floating around here (at bigger walmarts)

  4. I love this one! And I agree, I definitely taste cheesecake/cream cheese. If I didn't see the container I would assume it was a raspberry cheesecake ice cream. I would have liked more raspberry swirl, but still a great flavor!

  5. Just tried this tonight and it def reminds me of wedding cake. However nothing can be too sweet for me so I disagree with you thinking it was sweet. I did enjoy the swirl, it reminded me of a delicious jam, and there were a TON of cake bits everywhere. But like you Dubs I think Triple Chocolate cake and red velvet are tastier!

  6. This ice cream is awesome, hard to find haven't be able to find it since 2011.

    Becca Abbot, Me

  7. sorry, they have been retiring all the Duff flavors

  8. PLEASE bring back raspberry wedding cake ice cream!!!!!! It is the BEST ice cream!!

  9. Biue Bunny needs to bring back the "I do" " I do" Wedding cake ice cream. It was awesome. This was the best combination of flavors I have ever tried.If Blue Bunny won't bring it back then another company needs to make it.PLEASE!!!

  10. Omg I want this wedding cake flavor back so bad. This was my absolute favorite

  11. Please bring back I do I do wedding cake ice cream 🍦, I was literally buying it buy the case just before it discontinued. I love ❤️ it and Split Decision. The vanillla I cream with creamy fudge straight down the middle of this delightful cool treat! 😊. Thank You

  12. The I do I do wedding cake ice cream was the best I ever tasted! I would love to taste it again!

  13. Yesss please bring back I do I do wedding cake ice cream I'm so I'm love wit that ice cream its the best and my #1 favorite please please please bring it back it's so delicious!!!!

  14. My favorite ice cream is the i do I do wedding cake. Please bring it back!


*** All comments are moderated ***
Expect a delay before they are posted