Friday, July 31, 2026

Canton Creamery Cookie Dough M&M


Who is Canton Creamery? Well, for starters, it's Canton, CT, not Canton, MA, and this is their website (which could use a bit of work to be honest). They are available at Big Y stores, which is where I found me a pint of....

Canton Creamery Cookie Dough M&M Ice Cream
(no description on pint or website)

That's concerning.

Still nothing?

Still nothing?!?!

It's a fine mild base (no major gums or stabilizers), but what can't I find the mix-ins.... that's it, I can't take it any more....

----- SLICE -----

Suspicions confirmed... this pint is BORING. There's like 4 pea sized chunks of cookie dough and I would hazard a guess that if you reassembled the obliterated M&Ms that there would be 7 or 8 of them... holy cow that's sad.... so so so sad.

So this isn't a low quality ice cream. It's pretty solid like ice cream used to be, but I've been saving this one for a "rainy" day when I needed a quality cookie dough and M&M fix. I am thoroughly disappointed right now... no, that's just true.... I'm ticked off honestly. What's the point of 320 calories per serving if there's a bare minimum amount of flavor? I'm not going to toss a quality ice cream base, but it's going to need some additions to get it back in the game.

On Second Scoop: still boring.... like their website.... maybe they don't have ice cream photos on their website because all their flavors are like this..... nah, this was hopefully a bum pint.... hopefully.

Verdict?  WHERE ARE THE MIX-INS?!
Buy Again?  It'll be awhile before I try another flavor

Allergy Note: manufactured in a facility with other allergens
click for nutrition facts


2 comments:

  1. The artist formerly known as Foodette here! I had this pint and had the same experience and man, it was so disappointing. My pint also had the strangest texture, almost slimy. Couldn’t finish it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And now I really don't want to bother trying them again!

      Delete

*** All comments are moderated ***
Expect a delay before they are posted