[New for Nov 2025] Man, just when I thought Wendy's was getting me back in to the Frosty fold, they sell me this junk. Let's see what I just tossed in the trash...
Wendy's Snickerdoodle Cookie Frosty Fusion
vanilla frosty with snickerdoodle sauce and snickerdoodle cookies
I think you know that I am not a fan of people saying they threw food in the trash (because I often dont believe them), but we bought two of these frostys and they both went in to the trash after several bites.
Sure, they were packed full of crunchies with my wife thinking maybe a few too many crunchies, but the sauce is not good. It's got the cinnamon burn without any much cinnamon flavoring. There's no sugar sweetness to balance things out. It's just burn and crunch.
Let's check the ingredients! Molasses, natural flavor, and spice are in the sauce, but no cinnamon there. The cookies have cinnamon listed under the "contains 2% or less" section of the ingredients. That explains why we didn't really taste much cinnamon flavor.
Man, I hate how many cinnamon flavors products are no longer flavored with plain old cinnamon. Instead you get that weird fireball-like heat that doesnt taste like cinnamon to me.
If I sound a little harsh, please remember that I did like both the caramel crunch and strawberry poptart frosty fusions.
Ugggg. I guess we are starting 2026 with a thud then. I want my ten bucks back.
[To wash the bad vibes away, we headed over to Ben & Jerry's for some real ice cream]
Verdict? gross
Buy Again? no chance
Buy Again? no chance
I couldn't agree more. The caramel crunch and strawberry pop tart frosty fusions were so delicious but this one was a huge disappointment. YUCK!
ReplyDeleteWow! Im not sure I’ve ever seen you start a review with that much disgust!! Thats says a lot. As always, thanks for doing the heavy lifting so we dont have to. I hope Wendy’s see this.
ReplyDeleteThanks for taking one for the team as always. I was curious about this, but will steer clear.
ReplyDelete