Strawberry Showdown 2017

[Both New for 2017] Everyone remembers I love strawberry ice cream right? It's not a daily driver for me, but when the mood hits, a nice strawberry flavor can really be great. Now in general, I would do an actual side by side comparison for one of these fights. However, I only ever see the Yuengling's Strawberry ice cream by my work and my free Gelato Fiasco Strawberry Gelato sample is at my home so we are going to improvise a little.

Yuengling Strawberry Ice Cream
Gelato Fiasco Strawberry Gelato

Yuengling Butterbeer Ice Cream

[New for March 2017] Yesterday, Yuengling's Ice Cream announced their two new flavors for 2017, Butterbeer and Strawberry. That's right, butterbeer ice cream, as inspired by Harry Potter butterbeer. I think "great!" because I picked up this pint last Friday and already have a review written of...

Yuengling Butterbeer Ice Cream

buttercream and butterscotch ice cream with a butterscotch swirl

Yuengling's Butter Pecan Ice Cream

[New for 2016] This is the last of the four new Yuengling's flavors that debuted for 2016. I don't know why it took so long to pop up in my area, and yes this is something Nick usually reviews, but I'm hungry and it's either this or Gifford's Power Play Fudge ice cream (announcement here).

Yuengling's Butter Pecan Ice Cream

Butter Pecan Ice Cream with Pecan Pieces

Yuengling's Cherry Vanilla Chunk Ice Cream

[New for 2016] Time for the third of four new 2016 flavors from Yuenglings Ice Cream. Cinnamon Churro wasn't my style, Cookies & Cream was pleasant enough, and I still haven't seen the new Butter Pecan flavor. That just leaves...

Yuengling's Cherry Vanilla Chunk Ice Cream

Cherry Vanilla Ice Cream with Cherry Chunks and Large Dark Chocolate Chips

Yuengling's Cookies & Cream Ice Cream

[New for 2016] I don't remember the last time I said it, but I think that you can get a good sense for a company by trying their take on the classic flavor combo of cookies & cream. It's a flavor that is simple in construction, easy to do well, and yet still easy to mess up. Thankfully my local Stop & Shop (Giant) has increased their shelf space for Yuengling pints so I can try....

Yuengling's Cookies & Cream Ice Cream

Vanilla Ice Cream with Old Fashioned Dark Chocolate Cookie Pieces

Yuengling's Cinnamon Churro Ice Cream

[New for 2016] You might remember that Yuengling was basically the first ice cream companies to mention a 2016 lineup Since then a whole lot of new ice cream has come out, and technically I only found one of their 2016 flavors, but it's the one I wanted to try first anyway.

Yuengling's Cinnamon Churro Ice Cream

Madagascar vanilla ice cream* with
baked churro pieces and a cinnamon swirl

Yuengling's Root Beer Float Ice Cream

Ever since I spied these new Yuengling pints at Stop & Shop (Giant), I've been debating which one I should try to show off the new form factor. Well, the mood (and the sale), finally hit today and I decided to try...

Yuengling's Root Beer Float Ice Cream

"Traditional Old Fashioned Root Beer Float"

Yuengling's Caramel Popcorn Ice Cream

[New for 2015] Alright, I decided to head out to a different Roche Bros in hopes of finding one of the other four new Yuenglings flavors that came out this year. Sure enough, they had the most interesting sounding flavor (and most colorful quart) of the bunch.

Yuengling Caramel Popcorn Ice Cream

"the taste of buttered popcorn with a caramel swirl"

Yuengling's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

[New for 2015] So we've gotten a few requests to pick up one of the new Yuengling Ice Creams, let's see if I can finally find some of their new stuff in my area. Now there are four new flavors to search for: Sea Salt Caramel Swirl (which features the caramel ice cream from their Black & Tan flavor), Orange Cream, Caramel Popcorn and...

Yuengling's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream

rich Belgian chocolate ice cream swirl with peanut butter ice cream,
peanut butter swirls and peanut butter cup pieces

Yuengling Vanilla Fudge Chunk with Pretzels Ice Cream

....and I just deleted the post I had written... really? 'cause the last two weeks haven't been busy enough, I have to delete all my thoughts from a few hours ago? Well, that's what I get for taking notes in notepad without saving. Oh well, we all do it, so let's try this again: I went off looking for the new cookie cores at lunch but instead I came back with some Yuengling's ice cream that was on sale.

Yuengling Vanilla Fudge Chunk with Pretzels Ice Cream

Madagascar Vanilla Ice Cream, Fudge Swirl, Chocolate Chips and Chocolate Covered Pretzels

Yuengling's Spiced Pumpkin Roll Ice Cream Yuengling's Peppermint Crunch Ice Cream

I'll admit it, I really didn't want to do another pumpkin review. It's fun to do one review of it a year, but it feel's like I've had it a hundred times, and I really didn't want to do it again.... but Yuengling really wanted us to try it, I hate saying no to free ice cream... and I must admit it, I'm glad I agreed.

Yuengling Spiced Pumpkin Roll Ice Cream

Yuengling Peppermint Crunch Ice Cream

Yuengling's Black & Tan Ice Cream

[New for 2014] Alright, time to finally bring Yuengling's ice cream to the blog. For those who don't know, Yuengling (the brewer) has returned to the ice cream game after a 29 year hiatus.Why today? Well, because it was on sale today! There I am staring at two shelves worth of "Pennsylvania's finest" ice cream quarts, but only Chocolate Marshmallow and Black & Tan are frost free. Hmmm, chocolate marshmallow is tempting, but when you bring a new company to a blog, I think it's best to start with a bang.

Yuengling's Black & Tan Ice Cream

A Swirl of Rich Belgian Chocolate Ice Cream and Salty Caramel Ice Cream