Ben & Jerry's Non-Dairy Key Lime Pie

[New for 2026] While doublechecking that my local scoop shop still had the new Black raspberry flavor, I noticed the brandy new Key Lime Pie flavor! I was a big fan of the 2012 version, so why not grab a scoop of...

Ben & Jerry's Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert with Thick Graham Cracker Swirls

Jeni's Double Dough Ice Cream

[New for Summer 2023] I really do need to get more Jeni's on the blog. With price and quality differentials the way they are right now, there's no reason I cant treat myself to a pint of Jeni's now and then.

Today's review is going to be a review of what used to be a "lonely ghost" collab. That branding is gone, but who doesn't love a cookie dough ice cream that has some actual cookie dough flavoring in the base? That's the way cookie dough ice cream should be. I don't expect this one to disappoint, so let's dive in to....

Jeni's Double Dough Ice Cream

Chocolate chip cookie dough swirled into a buttery brown sugar custard

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream Bars

[New for 2026] I almost forgot that I had more new ice cream bars to try, but then the other day I was dying for a chocolate fix, so I bought the pint and bar version of....

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie Ice Cream Bars

chocolate ice cream with fudge brownies, dipped in a chocolatey coating with chocolate cookie pieces

Gifford's Cereal & Cream Ice Cream

[New for 2026] This is meant to be grapenut ice cream?? I bought it because I thought it was cereal inspired, but this could be better actually because I am a big fan of grapenut ice cream. If you havent tried it, you are missing out.

Gifford's Cereal & Cream Ice Cream

"vanilla ice cream packed with malted barley cereal nuggets"

Muddy Bites Strawberry Roundup

[New for 2026] I love the idea of Muddy Bites even if I dont love every flavor. Also, while I often get annoyed with companies constantly trying to re-flavor a product, there are times when it makes sense, like with these new...

Muddy Bites Strawberry Roundup Filled Waffle Cones

Toy Story Strawberry Shortcake Waffle Cone Snacks

Muddy Bites Hot Cocoa Waffle Cone Snacks

[New for Dec 2024] I finally bought these in December 2025 (because I'm not positive that I saw them in 2024, though I did know about them). I may have then accidentally shoved them behind a bunch of cookies in the cabinet and forgot to try them. Let's finally open a bag of... 

Muddy Bites Hot Cocoa Waffle Cone Snacks

(milk chocolate and marshmallow flavor)

What's your favorite Cookie Monster Ice Cream?

I do mean to sprinkle in local ice cream from time to time when I think the flavor (or the visuals) are good enough to be interesting, but then a few weeks will pass and that local ice cream just melts away.... However, I was looking over the pictures from our Friday night ice cream and I was surprised how well they turned out.

Rota Spring Farm Cookie Monster Ice Cream

vanilla ice cream loaded with Oreos and swirled with blue icing

Tillamook Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Bars

[New for 2026] Tillamook continues to keep mainstream ice cream alive with four new ice cream bars. We've got Tillamook Mudslide, Vanilla Bean, Mint Chocolate Chip, and...

Tillamook Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Bars

vanilla ice cream with crunchy cookies pieces dipped in a chocolaty coating