If I had to choose between the two flavors I’ve tried, I’d hands down choose their Dark Chocolate. The sparse mix-ins in this flavor make it hard to say I’d repurchase since the almonds are what really make this flavor complete. Maybe I got a bum pint* on mix-ins but when people are paying $10 a pint, there’s really no room for such an error. While I could recommend anyone to try Dark Chocolate at least once, I can’t say the same for this flavor.
I have to say though that this was a great experience being able to try a highly praised brand without hurting my wallet. The only problem is after trying these two flavors, I now want to try more of them. I guess those student loans can wait. So I want to hear from you guys, what flavor of Jeni’s is your favorite or which flavor would you like to see me review? If I’m going to be spending my own money, I want your input in helping me make a decision. I also wanted to thank my guide Lyndsay and Healthy Living Market once again for giving me an awesome tour and letting me try out these flavors!
Verdict? One of the best buttery ice cream bases but the lack of mix-ins hinder it’s potential
Buy Again? Not at $10 a pint, that’s for sure.
*Note: we have heard that some people have had good luck with this flavor (mix-in wise). If you've had it, whether chock full or not, let us know too!