Hmmm, looks all too familiar but don't worry, there's more swirls below!
The good news is that the simplicity of being All Natural has added that little spark that sets it apart from their very tame Salty Caramel. I don't know if there is a little bit of salt in the base, but it has just this little pop that mixes well with the clean texture of this all natural ice cream. To be honest, I'm not sure if the base is suppose to be straight (but mild) vanilla or have a hint of caramel, but I do know it is amusing me.
On Second Scoop: This is one of those flavors that grows on you every time you try it. Yes, it's basic, but it's a well done basic. I think it's easy to be bored with basic, but that's because too many companies have forgotten what basic means. Man I appreciate all natural product lines because it's the ice cream of my childhood all over again.
Breyers BLASTS Golden Oreo for example. When you're putting a tasty cookie in to an ice cream, it should be a hit, but Breyers messed it up. Sure some people like the Breyers version, but it could have been ten times better. Do I have proof? Well, you're looking at it. Crushed Golden Oreo wafers on the lovely canvas we call Salted caramel. That's right, Salted Caramel Cookies 'n Cream. Man did it hit the spot last night and was even better tonight. It's such a nice clean texture mixed with fresh cookies, it's an excellent win. Breyers, this is how you should have done it. Turkey Hill, you feel free to use this idea :)
Verdict? Nice clean flavor
Buy Again? Yes