For a long time, my favorite flavor was Turkey Hill's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream.
It's a nice chocolate between layers of peanut butter. and I don't mean little wussy layers, I mean real LAYERS, the kind where if you put your spoon under some of them, a huge chunk of peanut butter covered in chocolate comes out. Great peanut butter to chocolate ratio as well. It's been awhile, but I remember the peanut butter also having a nice texture, slightly salty, to give it a nice overall balance with the chocolate. If you've never had it, give it a try.
Nutrition: 180 / 90 / 1 / 3