[2023-2024? based on probable 2 year shelf life that I need to confirm] I think I bought this because it was on sale.... looking at old reviews, I initially liked the strawberry but then was meh on the chocolate and vanilla flavors. So, I was going to give Oatly one more try, and then I did the thing where the pint falls into the basement freezer abyss only to return 3 months after it's best by date. Whoopsie. (I'm like this with mail in rebates as well). Let's crack it open (and then toss) a container of...

Oatly Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Non-dairy Frozen Dessert

Fairly amusing

Not the greatest tease but technically you can see stuff hiding.

That's respectably busy!
I rarely eat old ice cream, but just so it's not a total waste, I did try a few bites from the center of the pint (the freshest part of the container) and I can honestly say that this tastes like oatmilk. Shocking right? But seriously, I've tried cooking with Pacific Valley Vanilla Oat Milk (before they discontinued it) and this totally reminds me of that.
It does not remind me of cookie dough though....
Now, for whatever reason...... I decided to eat all of the cookie dough out of the pint... because I guess I just really wanted some cookie dough. The old dough isn't very flavorful at this point (if it ever was), but I went with it anyway.
So, if you never tried this one, I guess you didn't miss much.
Side note: this also debuted with banana split, but both are no longer listed. That same press release also mentioned the raspberry swirl flavor, but I don't know if I ever saw that one (and if I had, I probably would have bought it.... though maybe I saw it once but wasnt able to buy it at the time).
Feel free to leave your thoughts on Oatly in the comments!
Verdict? oatmilk-y
Buy Again? unlikely
Buy Again? unlikely

No comments:
Post a Comment
*** All comments are moderated ***
Expect a delay before they are posted