FatBoy Waffle Cone Ice Cream Sandwich Pops

[New for Early 2026] So I hit several stores this weekend hoping to find the new Ben & Jerry's Sundae pints. I didn't find them, but I am very happy and excited to report that I did find the brandy new....

FatBoy Waffle Cone Ice Cream Sandwich Pops

vanilla ice cream sandwich with caramel swirl dipped in chocolate coating and rolled in waffle cone pieces

branded wrapper always good

I didnt expect full coverage (and the other side has a bit less)

but check out this fun shot!

I take my first big bite and have two major thoughts.

One, if you were wondering if the waffle cone bits would stay crunchy, the answer is no.

Two, if you were wondering if this pop would be tasty, the answer is yes, very.

I very much enjoyed every bite of this pop. Yes, I was hoping for a bit more crunch probably, but this bad boy is using graham cracker wafers for the sandwich part and that makes for one very tasty flavor combo. Granted, I adore s'mores flavored things, so I am the target audience, but yeah, fun bites for sure. I was very much struggling with "this is great, I need to take bigger bites" versus "this is great, I need to take smaller bites so it lasts longer."

The swirl is fairly thin, so it wont jump out at you, but you could argue that's adding to the overall flavor profile.

At 3.5 fluid ounces, you will be torn between wanting another and knowing that maybe one is good enough for now. I was strongly tempted to grab another, but I held off.... though in the end I wonder up having a second snack anyway, so maybe I should have grabbed a second bar. 

Nice job on this one FatBoy! I can't wait to have another one tomorrow.... or tonight.... no no, I should wait until tomorrow... but I don't want to.... no, I'll wait.

photo courtesy of Sam's Club

Production Note: theimpulsivebuy posted a S'mores ice cream bar that was a limited edition exclusive at Sam's Club last year. This new pop appears to be a variation of that treat. Did any of you ever try that one before it disappeared? It's crazy to think that it was just $9.98 for a box of 12!!

On Second Scoop: I've already had my second and third bars (on different days). You know I'm big on texture, and the texture is a lot of fun here, as is the flavor. I thought I might get hung up on it not being a typical fresh cone crunch, but it really grew on me. I have to decide if I want the last bar tomorrow, or if I want to save it until I have another box in the freezer.

Verdict?  delicious
Buy Again?  I foresee many repeat purchases

allergy note: made on shared equipment