So what's the word on the street? Too much cookie, which is a shame really. I was stoked to finally see an ice cream sandwich made with a actual sugar cookie, but this sandwich just isn't balanced. The soft but somewhat dry cookie totally overwhelms the ice cream inside. I thought the caramel Ciao Bella sandwiches had trouble but the filling here is even more buried. I can't even comment on it because I could barely taste it. The cookie itself is pretty neat but I need to taste the ice cream in my ice cream sandwich, especially one with 70% of my saturated fat for the day.
I think I need to add the disclaimer that this isn't a bad sandwich, it's just that I hyped it up too much in my mind. When I made my own three twins sea salt caramel sandwiches, I went with a giant slab of ice cream and it was awesome. I wanted that same experience here and it just didn't happen.
Verdict? too much cookie
Buy Again? probably not, but I will try the other flavor